Is Bioidentical Hormone Replacement Therapy Better for You?


An Analogy for Understanding Bioidentical Hormone Replacement

A few years ago, I was bitten twice in the foot by a black widow spider. I was rushed by ambulance to an emergency room where there was an on-call toxicologist. After several rounds of morphine and valium, neither of which relieved my pain, the toxicologist was paged. When he arrived, he went over treatment options for my partner and I.

“Normally, the symptoms should have subsided by now,” the doctor explained, “because it hasn’t, you should consider an antivenin.” Antivenin is created by milking venom from the desired snake, spider, or insect. The venom is then diluted and injected, usually into a horse, but sometimes a sheep or goat. The animal undergoes an immune response to the venom, producing antibodies against the venom’s active molecule which can then be harvested from the animal’s blood and used to treat patients, like myself, whose symptoms haven’t subsided naturally. There’s a catch, however. Some individuals may react to the antivenom with an immediate anaphylaxis or a delayed serum sickness. A small percentage of patients die from the antivenon treatment.

My partner did a quick cost benefit analysis and made what must have been a difficult call, given I was completely out of it, deciding for the antivenin. As expected, the serum provided immediate relief and I was released from the hospital a short time later. My point here is not to suggest that antivenin and hormone replacement drugs are identical, rather it is to suggest 1) that horse serum can be nasty stuff, 2) there are cost/benefits to be weighed with almost every type of medical treatment, and 3) deciding to use HRT is only the beginning of the maze when it comes to treating the symptoms of menopause.

Bioidentical versus Synthetic

Many experts argue that Premarin and Prempro are not ideal hormone replacement products because they’re derived from urine of pregnant horses. Some doctors prefer the synthetic estrogen, estradiol (found in Est0race, Climara, Estring), because it’s chemically identical to the kind made by women’s ovaries. This is why it is described as “bioidentical.” Between 2003 and 2008, prescriptions for bioidentical, estradiol-based products rose from 22 to 35 percent of the supplemental estrogen market, while those for Premarin tablets fell from 53 to 35 percent, according to IMS Health.

Some compounding labs will even customize estradiol creams or patches for individual patients. Is it any wonder that bioidentical HRT makes sense to many women? After all, who wants to ingest something derived from horse urine, whether it’s been proven effective or not?

Yet, whether bioidentical estrogen and progesterone are safer or superior is yet unproved. It’s entirely possible that they have the same risks that Prempro, the horse urine byproduct used in the controversial Women’s Health Inititative [WHI] study. There is some speculation that the body takes the estrogen it’s given and changes its form so that a woman may use estradiol only to have her body turn it into estrone sulfate, the main ingredient in Premarin and Prempro. This suggests that the main advantage touted by advocates of bioidentical HRT, is specious at best.

It’s all rather confusing, but one thing is for certain, not all hormones are equal as they relate to pharmacology and physiology, and instead of condemning all hormones equally, a la the WHI study, more research is needed so that we don’t have to rely on generalizations that are too big to be useful.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Amy Roost

Amy Roost’s passion is public health and policy. She earned a BA in political science from George Washington University and an MA in International Affairs from Columbia University in New York. Amy has worked as a press aide for Charles Percy, chairman of the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee, and many non-profit organizations. She served as the Executive Director of the Chaparral Educational Foundation, the Del Mar Schools Foundation and The Thriver’s Network. In 2006, she founded Co-optimize, a business assisting independent bookstores across the country with various business services. She has spent the past several years developing and marketing the company’s proprietary software. Presently, Amy is moving in the direction of social entrepreneurship. As a blogger and marketing strategist, she hopes to speak for others whose voices are not yet being heard in the policy and research arenas.


  1. I cannot get straight answers between MD Peers within the same departments. So far I see little beyond CYA replies.
    I fell into the 50% failure rate of mammograms due to then unknown dense breast tissue.
    Surgery and radiation is behind me and I now want back on HRT.I am interested in bioidenticals. is there a similar level with breast cancer estrogen receptor as with my prior two pill, EEMG and Medoxyprogesterone. I am intact, but for quality of life, I am pushing for return to HRT. The vaginally inserted type was prescribed, but at $89.00 at walMart, there is no way I can afford it. Any ideas please, I am in North San Diego County.

    • I understand your frustration. I share it. My best recommendation is to find a doc who specializes in women’s hormone health with a functional medicine approach.

      One of Lucine’s goals is to begin delineating who should take which hormones and under what circumstances. There are millions of women like yourself who just want answers, based on data. Unfortunately, those data don’t exist and as I written about on our Facebook page, funding for gathering those data, either in the form or grants or investment just doesn’t exist. It’s not viewed as a ‘sexy’ enough problem for investors or it’s viewed as ‘too complicated’. Both of which are true, but it doesn’t negate that fact that women are suffering need those data, sexy or not, complicated or not. We are determined to find answers for you and others. It may take us a while, but we’ll get there eventually. In the mean time, if you find anything that other women would be interested in learning, please let us know. We’d be happy to post it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Previous Story

Being a Woman and a Marine

Next Story

Diet Drinks: Helpful or Harmful to Kick the Sugar Habit

Latest from Hormones