covid thiamine deficiency

COVID Notes: A Calcium Tsunami in COVID Infected Cardiomyocytes

8082 views

In July 2020, I became ill with what may have been something related to COVID, or not, as there was no testing that was easily available to confirm. The illness affected my heart function. Since then I have been following the research on COVID-related heart damage. Over recent months, several studies have been published showing the mechanisms of viral-related heart damage. It appears that viral heart infection is not exclusive to COVID. So it is entirely possible that what I experienced was not COVID, but just some random and bizarre viral infection. Nevertheless, my experience was odd enough that it may be of use to someone and so I am publishing it here along with some thoughts on potential mechanisms.

Some Background

I am a 53-year-old, generally healthy, though overweight by traditional standards, powerlifter with several world records in my federation, age, and weight class. I train 4-5 days per week and have for the last several years. Before that, I did Crossfit and before that, I played water polo for decades. Physical fitness has always been a part of my lifestyle. I eat healthy, and largely organic, and I don’t drink or smoke. I have not taken any medications in over a decade, not even ibuprofen. Although as a young woman, I, like so many young women, inhaled ibuprofen on a monthly basis along with a laundry list of other medications prescribed by physicians. My one remaining chemical vice pre-infection was a cup of iced coffee every morning after workout. Now, post-infection, I cannot tolerate even a minimal amount of caffeine.

As the pandemic was approaching, we purchased some home gym equipment and put a gym in our living room to keep training. We have continued to train at home throughout. For the first few months, we rarely left the house. Prior to the closures, I would access a variety of bodywork modalities to help my body maintain its ability to lift heavy and to manage longstanding neck and shoulder injuries. This included regular massage and several different forms of chiropractic care. With the closures, I did not access these services for months and it was taking a toll. In May, I began accessing some chiropractic care again. At the end of June at one particular appointment, I think I was exposed. A few days later, I became ill, but not in the traditional manner described by the media or the studies.

Asymptomatic COVID or Something Else?

It began with odd bouts of breathlessness when climbing stairs or doing normal everyday activities. Since I had no fever or cough and felt fine, I went on with life. A few days passed and just before we were to drive to our cabin for some rest and relaxation, I developed lower GI symptoms such that I remained home. That also passed within a few days and I thought whatever it was had resolved. I was wrong. Soon after, absolute exhaustion hit, and my blood pressure and heart rate climbed. Over the next few weeks, I battled increasingly high blood pressure (150-160s/110-120s), heart rate (90s – my normal is in the 50s), edema, and pounding pressure in my head. I had no fever but experienced intense hot flashes or flushing. My pulse ox remained in the mid-90s throughout.  It felt like everything was out of sync, including my autonomic system.

Among the oddest experiences were the episodes of pressure, swelling, and blood pressure spikes. I would get these seemingly random bouts of pressure in my head and heart. I would be sitting or standing, it didn’t matter, and all of a sudden everything would go haywire. I could watch my hands and feet swell up multiple times their normal size over a matter of minutes. The pressure in my head would increase, and along with it, my blood pressure would spike. On several occasions, I worried that I would stroke out or have a heart attack. Additionally, my pulse was irregular and thready. My heart fluttered and skipped beats. I could feel the missed beats and arrhythmic patterns through the blood pressure cuff. Needless to say, I could not function for several weeks and mostly slept, well more than normal.

I could not work out the first week at all. I could barely stay awake. The second week, I could lift a little, but had to rest for several minutes after each very light lift. I would become out of breath, my heart would pound out of my chest and pulse through the back of my skull and neck. Again though, my O2 levels per the pulse oximeter were fine. My heart rate was high for me, but otherwise fine. My blood pressure was not, so I was very careful. During this time, I could not put a barbell on my back to squat. When I did, it felt as if there was just too much pressure in my head. It was horribly disconcerting and harkened thoughts of stroke. It took about 5-6 weeks before I could put the barbell on my back without the excessive pressure and return to some semblance of a normal but light workout. It took another few weeks before I could do any volume.

While all of this was happening, I still took no medications, except aspirin periodically to thin my blood in the event I was potentially clotting. I continued my normal regimen of 200mg of Allithiamine. I may have upped it to 300mg a few times. I upped my magnesium from 100-200mg per day to ~400mg depending upon the blood pressure. When my pressure spiked, I would pop a magnesium or two to bring it down a bit. I began taking fish oil again, about 2 grams per day. I continued my normal multi-vitamin along with extra vitamins A, D, and K2 and added 1-2 g of vitamin C. I had been taking a zinc, and copper combination since March as well.

At about 3 weeks in, I sought more specialized chiropractic care where the practitioner adjusts the atlas. I had used it previously before everything shut down and hoped it would help relieve some of the pressure in my head and neck. Soon after, I also began acupuncture to help clear some of the edema and manage my blood pressure better. Over the next several weeks, everything gradually improved. It was probably 8+ weeks or so before I felt more normal, before the edema subsided completely, and everything stabilized.

The experience was so strange though that I am not sure what exactly happened. Was this what might be deemed an asymptomatic or mild expression of COVID or some other viral infection? Because I was not able to be tested I’ll never know but in recent weeks research has come out detailing more of the mechanisms involved in COVID-related heart infections. One particular study struck me as a possible mechanistic explanation of what I imagine might have been happening. This study, together with some insight into mitochondrial function, suggests a picture of heart stress, provoked by the virus that was functionally similar to wet beriberi despite the fact that I was taking thiamine. I suspect the mechanism identified in this study against the backdrop of the individual’s underlying mitochondrial fitness may determine COVID morbidity and mortality in cases where the heart is preferentially affected.

The Ca2+ Tsunami in COVID Infected Cardiomyocytes

The study, SARS-CoV-2 direct cardiac damage through spike-mediated cardiomyocyte fusion, involved a series of experiments investigating the physiological and electrochemical properties of COVID-infected cardiomyocytes. The cells were derived from an autopsy of a 35-year-old woman who died suddenly in her sleep. She was three months postpartum and in the week prior had experienced mild fever, and cough, and had been light-headed but no other symptoms. At autopsy, she tested positive for COVID but per the report had no evidence of lung infiltration. To clarify the cause of death, myocardial cells were examined. What they found was that while the virus had not affected her lungs, viral proteins were identified in her the cells of her heart.

Through a series of tests and experiments, the researchers discovered that the viral proteins infected the electromechanically coupled cardiomyocytes building a bridge between cells, such that the virus was able to disturb the electrical potential/rhythm of the heart muscle. These cell-to-cell conduits then provided the

…pathoanatomical substrate for aberrant electrophysiological activity, electro-mechanical dysfunction, and fatal arrhythmia.

Additionally, they found that the altered electro-physiology in the infected cells was marked by prolonged action potentials, delayed after polarizations, and erratic beating frequency e.g. notable dysrhythmia. Importantly, they observed a pathological calcium (Ca2+) flux, which they describe as ‘tsunami-like waves’.

We suggest that SARS-CoV-2 spike glycoprotein-induced membrane changes directly injure CMs [cardiomyocytes], heightening cardiac arrhythmia risk even at low viral load and in the absence of widespread lymphocytic myocarditis-mediated tissue destruction.

The low viral load and the Ca2+ tsunami are what struck me most. Could it be that in some individuals, who are predisposed either genetically or epigenetically, the virus preferentially affects heart cells largely bypassing the lungs? In this case, a low viral load would be sufficient to cause problems, particularly, if the mechanism identified in this case holds. While it is clear that viral-infused cardiomyocytes would wreak havoc on the electrical potential of the heart, a sudden influx of calcium, well, that could be deadly, particularly if, as the report suggests, the cardiomyocytes are fused. The electrical potential would quickly overwhelm the cells’ ability to re-establish rhythm.

COVID, Calcium, and Cardiac Function

Backing up just a bit, the activity of cells like the cardiomyocytes, neurons, and muscles, is dependent upon a tightly choreographed series of changes in ion flux. See figure 1. With stimulus, sodium (Na+) channels open and Na+ floods the cell. This is the action potential mentioned above. Immediately following Na+, potassium (K+) channels open and K+ flows out, slowly at first and then more quickly as more channels open, and with it, Ca2+ comes rushing into the cell. The outflow of potassium prevents additional repolarization for a brief period while the buildup of Ca2+ feedbacks and eventually closes the Ca2+ channels. All of this happens within milliseconds and is highly regulated. If the timing is off or any of these ions are out of balance, arrhythmias develop.

COVID Notes - calcium heart function
Figure 1. Action potential of the cardiomyocyte.

Of these ions, it is the Ca2+ influx that is responsible for signal transduction, for setting into motion pathways that tell the cell how to respond to external and internal stimuli. As such, calcium homeostasis is of critical importance for cell function. A rapid influx of supraphysiological levels of Ca2+, as was evidenced in the study above, would induce a hyper-contractible state, disturb the timing of the electrical signals, and eventually, completely overwhelm the capacity to clear the excess, invoking apoptotic and necrotic death pathways depending upon mitochondrial ATP availability. Each of these markers has been found in the COVID-infected heart. These same disturbances may be also found in a condition called wet beriberi – thiamine deficiency that affects the heart. Similarly, cardiomyopathy, dyspnea (breathlessness), and elevated troponin, other common findings attributed to the COVID heart, are also associated with cardiac beriberi. Given my research on thiamine deficiency/beriberi, I cannot help but wonder if what we are seeing in COVID heart patients is some manifestation of the same process.

Although electrochemical research on both COVID and thiamine deficient myocardial function is lacking, as much of the research appears to focus on gross morphological changes mediated by inflammatory infiltrates, and we do not know if the Ca2+ tsunami identified in the aforementioned study is common across both disease processes, it is logically possible. Inasmuch as mitochondria provide the energy substrate that permits contraction and relaxation of the cardiomyocyte as well as Ca2+ management and sequestration, mitochondrial function may sit at the nexus of virally mediated cardiac events. To the extent that thiamine is critical for each of the key pathways involved in ATP production, insufficiency would impair these actions. And finally, since mitochondrial fitness is unique to the individual, this might explain why, even when there is clearly visible cardiac damage, symptom expression is mild or absent altogether in some individuals but deadly in others. This may be what is happening with athletes who are COVID positive and display limited symptomology but develop myocarditis. This may have been the case with me as well. Again though, without proper testing, this is speculation on my part. Nevertheless, the Ca2+ tsunami aptly describes a potential underlying mechanism for what I experienced.

If this turns out to be correct, the questions then become 1) why does COVID preferentially affect the heart and not the lungs in some individuals, 2) are the mitochondria the determining factor of severity and survival, and if so, 3) are there things we can do to support the mitochondria and maximize survival? While I do not know the answer to question 1, I have argued from the beginning of this pandemic that the determining factor in COVID morbidity and mortality comes down to mitochondrial fitness. To the extent mitochondrial fitness is determined by nutrient availability, thiamine especially, the answer to question 3, is yes, we can do something to improve outcomes. In a subsequent post, I will explore these questions more closely.

We Need Your Help

More people than ever are reading Hormones Matter, a testament to the need for independent voices in health and medicine. We are not funded and accept limited advertising. Unlike many health sites, we don’t force you to purchase a subscription. We believe health information should be open to all. If you read Hormones Matter, and like it, please help support it. Contribute now.

Yes, I would like to support Hormones Matter. 

COVID Notes: Random Thoughts On Brain and Immune Function

3994 views

This is the third in a series of short posts adapted from Twitter threads contemplating various aspects of the COVID-19 pandemic. The first two posts can be found here and here, and of course, on Twitter.

COVID, the Brain, and Immune Function

The neuroinvasive potential of SARS‐CoV2 may play a role in the respiratory failure of COVID‐19 patients.

“The most characteristic symptom of patients with COVID‐19 is respiratory distress, and most of the patients admitted to the intensive care could not breathe spontaneously…”

…where the brainstem was heavily infected…”

Key sentence: could not breathe spontaneously and brainstem involvement. Reading further we get thalamic involvement – as was reported in COVID-19–associated Acute Hemorrhagic Necrotizing Encephalopathy: CT and MRI Features.

As soon as I see this pattern, brainstem degradation>thalamic involvement, I immediately think dysautonomia>beriberi>thiamine deficiency>mito-hypoxia>disrupted immune function>inflammation overkill>leaky BBB >leaky junctions.

Then a few, more philosophical questions, niggle in the background. I have long had this theory that these pathogens have always already been with us and are just ‘activated’ when the circumstances align. I have no real basis for this and certainly much evidence against it.

But the idea remains – what if everything was already there? That the threats that we face are not entirely external but internal as well. This doesn’t mean that there are not external pathogens to which we fall prey, there absolutely are, but what if we constitutionally mirror those pathogens – they exist in us already but remain quiescent, mostly, until some confluence of events activates them.

If that were the case, then the potential for any pathogen to ‘reach’ any part of the body, the brain included, would not be so much about the uniqueness of the pathogen, although that would play a role certainly, but more about the uniqueness of the ‘host’.

This would then bring us back to Matzinger’s danger theory, where the immune system has advanced beyond the overly simplistic self vs non-self model – because everything is self, the pathogens were always already a part of us, and it is our response to them that engenders danger.

That brings us back to host response being the key variable to address with any illness. And with that, two questions. 1) what does the individual need to survive/be healthy and 2) are they getting it?

Reframed for this pandemic. 1) What molecular resources does the patient require to mount an effective immune response, with the appropriate amount of inflammation at the appropriate time?  2) Are they getting them? Likely they are not, because they are ill, sometimes seriously.

Reframed one more time. 1) What are the molecular resources one needs to beat this illness altogether – to be an asymptomatic carrier? 2) Are they getting them?

In this regard, everything comes back to host resources availability. That places the determinants of health versus illness squarely onto host health or more specifically, host mitochondrial health because the question always comes back to mitochondrial fitness, to the energy/ATP needed to either stave off illness altogether or fight it and survive if this fails.

Then where the pathogen attacks becomes an equation that includes equal parts pathogen to host variability e.g. host genetics/epigenetics/diet/lifestyle/environment etc., which is moderated by energy availability.

And from that perspective, as meandering and incompletely argued as it was, maybe it still provides a clue to how we fight this – bolster host defenses. Maybe that’s too simple in the age of technology. Maybe not.

We Need Your Help

More people than ever are reading Hormones Matter, a testament to the need for independent voices in health and medicine. We are not funded and accept limited advertising. Unlike many health sites, we don’t force you to purchase a subscription. We believe health information should be open to all. If you read Hormones Matter, and like it, please help support it. Contribute now.

Yes, I would like to support Hormones Matter. 

COVID-19 and Thiamine: An Interview with Dr. Derrick Lonsdale

9875 views

In the summer 2013, a geneticist we were seeing for my daughter ordered a test. Little did I know that test would contribute to a change in the course of my daughter’s life as well as a new area of study and advocacy for my career. This is my first time to write for Hormones Matter, so let me start by introducing myself. I am Kristi Wees and I am a pediatric patient advocate with EmpoweredAdvocacy.com as well as a national consultant for patient advocacy, empowerment, and engagement in the field of pediatric genetics. I was trained as a chemist at Penn State University with graduate training at UCLA. It was the journey that my daughter’s health took our family on that made me realize exactly why I had studied chemistry.

Fast forward to 2020, nearly 7 years later and now a pandemic with COVID-19, and I again realize how that 2013 test has sent us on an incredible journey. That 2013 test was for transketolase, which is a blood test to determine a vitamin (thiamine, B1) insufficiency. At the time, my daughter was struggling with autistic-like behaviors, severe fatigue, suspected mitochondrial disease, gastrointestinal concerns, severe food intolerances, and chemical sensitivities. The future looked bleak and hopeless.

After this test result came back, I began to search the literature about thiamine and found the work of Dr. Derrick Lonsdale. With guidance and a prescription from our medical team, we began our daughter on thiamine supplementation. In 2016,  I had the distinct honor of meeting Dr. Lonsdale in person. In 2019, I had the honor of interviewing him with Patricia Lemer for an episode called, “I Have A Child Who…Has Tantrums”.

Dr. Lonsdale
Our first meeting in 2016, from left to right: Kristi Wees (author of this post), Dr. Derrick Lonsdale, and Patricia Lemer (author of Outsmarting Autism).

A few weeks ago, I was reading the medical literature (here, here, and here) and watching anecdotal reports (here) regarding COVID-19 and began to see some clues that made me think of Dr. Lonsdale’s work on thiamine. I reached out to him via email and he shared with me that he too was seeing similar red flags and that he was frustrated because at 96 years old, and having dedicated his life to research on this vitamin, he believed it could be helping so many critically ill patients. He asked if I had any ideas about how to help him get the word out.

Here is the idea we came up with: a recorded interview. Dr. Lonsdale is a gentleman with whom I have come to know as a friend, mentor, and researcher and whose body of work helped my child thrive. I believe he possesses wisdom that has been forgotten and largely ignored by modern medicine. Listen to the interview, you won’t be disappointed.

Interview With Dr. Derrick Lonsdale: Thoughts on COVID-19

Dr. Derrick Lonsdale’s thoughts on COVID19 from Empowered Advocacy on Vimeo.

Shortly after releasing the video last week I came across this study: Intravenous Thiamine Is Associated With Increased Oxygen Consumption in Critically Ill Patients With Preserved Cardiac Index. Which again confirms Dr. Lonsdale’s conviction that thiamine can greatly improve the current situation in many ICU’s nationwide.

After treatment with thiamine, and many dietary, environmental and lifestyle changes, plus a whole lot of answered prayers, my daughter is thriving today with no residual behavioral, medical, neurological, developmental or learning challenges. Could thiamine also help overcome COVID-19? Possibly.

We Need Your Help

More people than ever are reading Hormones Matter, a testament to the need for independent voices in health and medicine. We are not funded and accept limited advertising. Unlike many health sites, we don’t force you to purchase a subscription. We believe health information should be open to all. If you read Hormones Matter, like it, please help support it. Contribute now.

Yes, I would like to support Hormones Matter.